Should cost analysis, sometimes called “should-cost modeling,” is a method used to estimate what a product or service should cost based on a detailed understanding of its components, materials, labor, overhead, and other cost drivers. Unlike relying solely on supplier quotes or market prices, this approach builds a cost model from scratch, considering factors like:
Raw materials: What are the base materials, and what’s their market cost?
Labor: How much time and skill are required, and what are the associated labor rates?
Manufacturing processes: What equipment, technology, or processes are involved, and what’s their cost impact?
Overhead and profit margins: What are reasonable overhead costs and supplier profit expectations?
Logistics and other expenses: What are the costs for shipping, packaging, or other ancillary services?
By analyzing these elements, procurement teams create a transparent cost baseline that reflects what a supplier should reasonably charge. This data-driven approach helps validate supplier pricing, identify cost-saving opportunities, and strengthen negotiation leverage.
In procurement, knowledge is power. Should cost analysis equips buyers with the insights needed to make informed decisions and avoid overpaying. Here are some key benefits:
Improved Negotiations
Armed with a detailed cost breakdown, procurement professionals can challenge inflated supplier quotes and negotiate prices closer to the “should cost” benchmark. This fosters fairer pricing and stronger supplier relationships.
Cost Optimization
By identifying high-cost components or inefficiencies in the production process, teams can collaborate with suppliers to explore alternatives, such as cheaper materials or streamlined processes, without sacrificing quality.
Supplier Transparency
Should cost analysis encourages open discussions with suppliers about cost structures. This transparency can lead to more collaborative partnerships and long-term cost reductions.
Risk Mitigation
Understanding cost drivers helps procurement teams anticipate price fluctuations due to market changes (e.g., raw material shortages) and develop strategies to mitigate risks.
Strategic Sourcing
Should cost models provide a foundation for evaluating suppliers, comparing bids, and selecting partners that align with cost and quality goals.
Conducting a should cost analysis involves a systematic process. Here’s a step-by-step overview:
Define the Scope
Identify the product or service to analyze. For example, is it a machined part, an electronic component, or a service like logistics?
Gather Data
Collect information on materials, labor rates, manufacturing processes, and other cost factors. This may involve market research, supplier discussions, or input from engineering teams.
Build the Cost Model
Break down the product or service into its components and assign costs to each element. Use tools like spreadsheets, cost estimation software, or industry benchmarks to create a detailed model.
Validate Assumptions
Cross-check your cost estimates with real-world data, such as supplier quotes, industry standards, or historical pricing. Adjust the model as needed to ensure accuracy.
Analyze and Compare
Compare the should cost estimate to supplier quotes or current pricing. Identify discrepancies and explore reasons for gaps, such as inefficiencies or excessive profit margins.
Negotiate and Optimize
Use the analysis to negotiate with suppliers, propose cost-saving ideas, or inform sourcing decisions. The goal is to align pricing with the should cost benchmark while maintaining quality and reliability.
While powerful, should cost analysis isn’t without challenges. It requires:
Accurate Data: Incomplete or outdated data can lead to inaccurate cost models.
Expertise: Building a reliable model often demands technical knowledge of manufacturing processes or industry-specific cost drivers.
Time and Resources: Conducting a thorough analysis can be time-intensive, especially for complex products.
Supplier Cooperation: Suppliers may be reluctant to share detailed cost information, necessitating careful relationship management.
Despite these challenges, the benefits of should cost analysis often outweigh the effort, especially for high-value or strategic purchases.
Should cost analysis is widely used across industries, including:
Manufacturing: To evaluate the cost of components like automotive parts or machinery.
Electronics: To assess the cost of circuit boards, chips, or consumer devices.
Construction: To estimate the cost of materials and labor for infrastructure projects.
Services: To benchmark costs for logistics, IT services, or consulting.
For example, an automotive company might use should cost analysis to determine the fair price of a transmission component. By modeling the cost of steel, machining, labor, and overhead, the company can negotiate with suppliers to reduce costs or switch to a more cost-effective design.
support@lassoprocurement.com
© 2025 Lasso Supply Chain Software LLC
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.
